Hypertrophy

Greek “excess” +  “nourishment”

Hypertrophy (Increase In Muscle Size)

Adding to changes in mass & volume (e.g., fluid and protein).

Two factors contribute to hypertrophy: SARCOPLASMIC (non-contractile elements) hypertrophy, which focuses more on increased muscle glycogen storage, in other words, refers to the increase in volume of fluid.

MYOFIBRILLAR (contractile elements) hypertrophy, which focuses more on increased myofibril size. 

 

When myofibrils become thicker, there is more surface area connecting individual myofibrils to one another. Strength is based on a muscle’s ability to generate tension, as the surface tension between individual fibers increases, the net result is greater force output from the entire muscle. As a muscle experiences myofibrillar hypertrophy, it becomes thicker and denser, not necessarily larger.

Performing a high volume of reps to fatigue produces the response of sarcoplasmic hypertrophy, an increase in size in the fluid-containing sarcoplasm around muscle cells, but not in the individual muscle fibers themselves. This is how a muscle can get larger without necessarily becoming stronger, it is simply storing more fluid which increases the total volume of the muscle cells.

 Claims

Doing exclusively heavy work for low reps, which always leaves considerable cellular energy reserves.

Several studies have discovered strong connections between muscle size and strength or performance.

  r values

  • 0 – 0.1: No relationship – these variables are not related
  • 0.1 – 0.3: Weak relationship – AKA, nothing to write home about
  • 0.3 – 0.5: Moderate relationship – now this is kind of interesting
  • 0.5 – 1.0: Large relationship – now this is VERY fascinating

 But how much of the variation in variable B (STRENGTH GAIN) can be accounted for by changes in variable A (MUSCLE GAIN)?

Muscle size and strength are often assumed to be linear in the literature (a larger muscle should be stronger).

But, This beautiful line is worth remembering.

“Correlation is not causation” means that just because two things correlate does not necessarily mean that one causes the other. … Correlations between two things can be caused by a third factor that affects both of them.

The study found a correlation of a pre-training correlation of r = 0.787 between biceps volume and biceps curl 1RM.

Is a larger muscle a stronger muscle? That is the ultimate question.

A 2017 12 Weeks, 3/week RCT Study (#28 Healthy Young Men#leg Extension# 4 Sets# 10 Repetition#isolation Exercises # No Rm & Rest Period Between Sets Mentioned)
The researchers observed a group of men performing leg extension exercise and measured muscle activation and muscle size, attempting to link these changes to the gain in quadriceps strength.
The change in quadriceps size showed an r = 0.461 correlation with strength improvements, but the change in muscle activation had an r = 0.576 correlation with strength gains. Changes in muscle size contributed to 18.7% of strength gains, whereas changes in activation contributed to 30.6% of the strength gains.(PMID: 28239775)

NOTE: The subjects had not done lower body Resistance Training in over 18 months.

A 2014 12 Weeks, Study (#33 Healthy Untrained Young Men#3 Session/week Alternate Days# Bilateral Preacher Curls On Machine # D/b Unilateral Preacher Curls# 2 Sets For Week 1–2, 3 Sets (Unilateral) And 2 Sets (Bilateral)  For   Week 3–4, 3 Sets Of Both Exercises For Week 5–12 #  8–10 Repetition# 80% 1-rm #  #2-min Rest Between Sets)


A similar research using biceps training aimed to describe the link between muscle growth and activation and strength improvements by measuring muscle size and activation. 
The association between muscle growth and strength (r = 0.527) was shown to be highly correlated, however the relationship between changes in muscle activation and strength (r = 0.187) was not.
According to the results, muscle growth accounted for 27.7% of the biceps strength improvements, whereas EMG alterations (muscle activation) only accounted for 3.5% of the strength gains.(PMID: 24610245)

NOTE:The study is a little older and used less advanced muscle size measurements or didn’t use much weight during training, resulting in muscle growth but not significant strength gains.

In 2019 Study. Some researchers have argued that there is no association between muscle size and strength due to a lack of data on the subject. The authors point to a lack of direct studies studying different degrees of development and their relationship to strength improvements as a reason for their conclusion.(PMID: 31020548)

However, there have been other studies in which a subject group grew more muscle and strength than its competitors.(PMID:12436270)(PMID:7095924)(PMID: 26272733)(PMID:16988909)

Strength is a skill, and exercising with heavier weights promotes strength development more effectively than training with lighter weights.(PMID: 12436270)

WHY? Changes in biceps activation did not correspond with strength improvements, although biceps hypertrophy did. Quadriceps growth and activation, on the other hand, were both associated to quad strength. In other words

Biceps                                                                        Quadriceps

Muscle Activation ≠ strength                       Muscle Activation = strength  

Muscle Hypertrophy = strength                 Muscle Hypertrophy = strength 

HYPOTHESIS 
Individual adaptations might be based on a muscle’s fundamental characteristics: voluntary activation (activation by choice). Smaller muscles can be intentionally stimulated to a greater extent than larger muscles – this is a general, not a rule & the primary muscles of the upper body are generally smaller than those of the lower body. In short, the biceps can voluntarily achieve at least 95% of their maximal involuntary contraction, whereas the quads are closer to 85% (PMID: 11870692). Other research has also found that squeezing the biceps and maximally engaging the biceps muscle with no load had similar results as subjects who performed Biceps curls with load (PMID: 27329807)

Well, the Hypothesis is that muscles with lower voluntary activation percentages, on the other hand, may be more dependent on neuromuscular adaptations than hypertrophy for strength improvements. Muscles with higher voluntary activation percentages, on the other hand, may be more dependent on growth for strength improvements since muscle activation is already near maximum.

Olympic weightlifters, powerlifters, and bodybuilders were studied for their thigh muscle area and related to squat 1RM in one fascinating master’s thesis. Although all three groups had equal thigh muscle areas, powerlifters and Olympic lifters were able to squat much higher than bodybuilders. The r =0.20 link between thigh muscle area and squat 1RM (weak relationship – nothing to write home about)

A 2016 8 Weeks, randomize Study (#nineteen Resistance-trained Men #3 Days/week# (Heavy) 2-4 Rep/set, (Moderate Hypertrophy-type)  8-12 Rep/ Set # 3 Sets# Flat Barbell Press#  Barbell Military Press#  Wide Grip Lat Pulldown# Seated Cable Row# Barbell Back Squat# Machine Leg Press#  Machine Leg Extension).
All individuals gained equal amounts of muscle thickness, however the heavy group’s squat 1RM increased much more than the moderate group’s (30% vs 16.8 %). Although the heavy group gained visibly more bench press strength than the moderate group (14.4% VS 10.5%, the difference was not statistically significant, demanding more investigation.
When it comes to strength, this study backs up the hypothesis that lower body muscles rely more on neuromuscular increases, whereas upper body muscles rely more on size growth.(PMID: 27928218)

A 2015 8 Weeks, Randomize Study,“(#33 Resistance-trained Men (5.7- 2.2 Years)#4 Days/week # (Heavy) 3-5 Rep 4 Sets With 90% 1rm,3-min Rest/ Set, (Moderate Hypertrophy-type)  8-12 Rep 4 Sets With 70% 1rm,1-min Rest/ Set #dexa # Muscle CSA # Thickness Of The Vastus Lateralis (Vl), Rectus Femoris (Rf), Pectoralis Major, And Triceps Brachii Muscles # Ultrasound Images # 1rm Strength In The Back Squat And Bench Press # Blood Samples Were Collected Serum Testosterone, Gh, Igf1, Cortisol, And Insulin Concentrations)

The heavy group not only increased their bench press (13.7% vs. 6.1 %), but they also gained more lean mass in their arms (5.2%  vs. 2.2%  increase), although both the heavy and high volume squat groups increased their hypertrophy and strength.
This supports the idea that upper body muscles rely on growth for strength, as the group that gained the most size also gained the most strength. This does, however, cast doubt on the assumption that lower body muscles aren’t as reliant on size for strength.
Area under the curve analysis showed larger GH and cortisol responses for HYPERTROPHY-TYPE TRAINING (8-12 REP) at Week 3 and cortisol alone at Week 10 as compared to HEAVY TRAINING (3-5 REP).
The GH and cortisol responses were lower for HYPERTROPHY-TYPE TRAINING (8-12 REP)  at Week 10, compared to Week 3, whereas the IGF1 response was lower for HEAVY TRAINING (3-5 REP).
During Week 3,Immediately post exercise, TESTOSTERONE levels in both groups were much higher than baseline, but by 30 minutes post exercise, they had returned to resting levels and by 60 minutes post exercise, they had decreased significantly below baseline. 
During Week 10, TESTOSTERONE levels remained similar to baseline at the time of exercise and at 30 minutes post exercise, but dropped considerably below baseline at 60 minutes post exercise.(PMID: 26272733)

NOTE: Keep in mind that strength is a skill, and heavy training is more specialized to a 1RM test, which might influence the findings of this research.

DEBATE

Does increase muscle activation result in increased strength gains? 
                                                  OR
Does an increase in muscle size result in an increase in strength? Because lifting heavy weights causes more muscle activation, whereas lifting light weights with muscle failure causes similar muscle activation. Can both training techniques lead to similar strength gains?
                                                 OR
Is Muscle Hypertrophy a by-product of Heavy Weight Lifting (Strength) and Nutrition?

Compared to between-subject analysis, analyses explain a substantially higher percentage of variance in strength growth.PMID: 28276188

Methods matter: the relationship between strength and hypertrophy depends on methods of measurement and analysis.PMID: 29967737

Strength increases in the first 4–6 weeks, with little to no noticeable hypertrophy.PMID: 453338 PMID: 17053104

Muscle hypertrophy and strength improvements have minimal relationships, with hypertrophy accounting for as little as 2–28 percent of the variation in strength development.PMID: 26767377 PMID: 30387185 PMID: 24610245

Homogenous groups of trained people (> 1 year RT), showing that hypertrophy accounts for a higher share of the variation in strength development as training status increases.PMID: 30387185 PMID: 8800357

Longer-term research on trained individuals suggests that hypertrophy, as measured by increases in body mass and fibre cross-sectional area, accounts for 65 percent of the variance in strength growth.PMID: 17277594 143729555

Cross-sectional studies involving elite athletes suggest that muscle size accounts for an even bigger amount of variance in strength than trained people. Human Kinetics PMID: 11990746

Short-term studies with untrained people may not completely capture the influence of hypertrophy on strength, although muscle hypertrophy adds to strength in the long term.

This hypothesis walks a fine line between science and open conspiracy theory. We don’t have a lot of direct data to work with, and the remaining is mostly observational and/or anecdotal.

Scroll to Top