1769:
For the first time, a French doctor isolated cholesterol from gallstones and later from various animal tissues. PMID: 9478044
1815:
It was rediscovered and named the compound “cholesterine”.PMID: 9478044 PMID: 20467214 PMCID: PMC2798703
1856:
- The concept of cholesterol began to take shape.
- The atherosclerotic plaque was discovered to be the fundamental cause of atherosclerosis.PMID: 9478044
1888:
The molecular structure of cholesterol was described due to a case report on sudden cardiac death of an 11-year-old child.PMID: 15547293
1900:
- While investigating whether an excess of protein in the diet was toxic and accelerated the aging process, Adult rabbits developed atherosclerosis after feeding large amounts of meat, eggs, and milk.PMID: 15102877 PMID: 23914012
- Plaques in aortas from atherosclerosis patients contained 20 times more cholesterol than normal aortas.PMID: 20467214 PMCID: PMC2798703 PMID: 16227628
- The first experimental was done in the production of atherosclerosis by feeding pure cholesterol to rabbits, thus eliminating proteins. However, similar experiments failed in dogs and rats. After 35 years, it came to know that dogs and rats, unlike rabbits, are quite efficient in converting cholesterol into bile acids.PMID: 20467214 PMCID: PMC2798703
- In the 1913, the “Lipid Hypothesis” emerged, suggesting a link between cholesterol levels in the blood and heart disease, which led to the understanding that dietary cholesterol intake can raise blood cholesterol levels.PMID: 27474223
- In the 1929,lipoproteins discovered.PMC2798703 PMID: 27474223
- In the 1950,Lot of Epidemiological studies emerged including the famous “Seven Countries Study” (Japan, Finland, the Netherlands, Yugoslavia, Italy, Greece, USA) by Dr.Ancel Keys also enzyme lipoprotein lipase, discovered. PMC2798703 PMID: 16227628 PMID: 15995167
- It became clearer that there was an association between lipoproteins and cardiovascular disease.
- In 1951,During and after World War II, after getting noticed that cholesterol is the precursor of hormones, everybody was eager to synthesize cholesterol.PMCID: PMC2798703
- Dietary intervention studies started that lowering cholesterol in diet was beneficial. PMID: 15547293 PMID: 32631832
- In 1953, Michael Oliver started an anti-cholesterol campaign with Sir John McMichael. Later, after the study in 1994, Michael Oliver changed his mind and became a promoter.PMID: 19042967
- In 1959, an inhibitor of cholesterol biosynthesis ‘STATIN’ a powerful inhibitor of HMG-CoA reductase was tested in rats and dogs. Serious side effects in animals (cataract, hair loss, lymphomas, cancer, rhabdomyolyse (muscles which leads to muscle death), deaths) were not reported; in 1963, a lawsuit was the end of this scandal.DOI:https://doi.org/10.1194/jlr.R600009-JLR200 PMID: 20467214
- In 1959, apolipoprotein A, B and C identified.PMID: 27474223
- In the 1960, studies started showing an association between elevated cholesterol levels and an increased risk of heart disease.
- In 1961, the American Heart Association recommended reducing dietary fat, limiting their dietary cholesterol intake to 300 milligrams per day, calorie intake and substituting saturated by polyunsaturated fats.
- In the 1970 development of cholesterol-lowering medications, particularly statins, began.
- In 1973,Nicotinic acid (Niacin, Vitamin B3) discovered. PMCID: PMC2798703
- In 1974, scientists showed that human cultivated (vitro study) fibroblasts can attach to LDL and stop HMG-CoA reductase from working. They also found out that the LDL receptor is needed for cells to take up LDL.PMID: 15995167 PMID: 9478044
- In 1979, the oxidative modification hypothesis was established. Its hypothesis states that the increase in cholesterol content in macrophages is attributed to the endothelial cell-modified LDL, which is oxidized and subsequently metabolized, resulting in Chemotaxis, the movement of an organism or entity in response to a chemical stimulus. PMID: 15995167
The “cholesterol wars” started in the 1950, peaked in the 1970, and weakened in the 1990.PMID: 19042967
1980:
- Cholesterol content in foods became a focus of nutrition education.
- Dietary guidelines began to reduce saturated fat and cholesterol intake to lower the risk of heart disease.
- It has been recommended that saturated fatty acid (SFA) intake be limited to <10% of total calories as a means of reducing risk for cardiovascular disease (CVD).PMID: 29899124
- Important roles of Cholesterol in the body.
1990:
- Added complexity to the understanding of cholesterol’s studies into the different subtypes of LDL cholesterol, particularly small, dense LDL particles.
- High blood cholesterol is not the only risk factor for heart disease.
2000:
- Studies highlighted the role of inflammation in atherosclerosis.
- New treatments for high cholesterol are developed.
- In 2002, an intestinal cholesterol absorption inhibitor discovered.
Present day:
- With ongoing studies, the cholesterol controversy continues to evolve.
Sir William Osler said: “The good physician treats the disease; the great physician treats the patient who has the disease”.
Summary:
In the early 1900, scientists discovered a link between cholesterol and vascular damage atherosclerosis, but many leading scientists did not consider its importance by thought it to be a natural and unavoidable component of aging. Later on, discovering cholesterol transportation in the blood stream, identifying HDL and LDL and large scale clinical studies showed an important relationship between the dietary fat and heart disease, a “lipid hypothesis” was established. These gave rise to fat-free or low fat dietary guidance, good and bad cholesterol, manufacturers producing low-fat products and medications.
Yet, the reaction of scientists was still mixed.
Additional Reading
The Journal of Lipid Research’s thematic review series: The Pathogenesis of Atherosclerosis. An interpretive history of the cholesterol controversy: Part I; Part II; Part III; Part IV;Part V
The Donald S. Fredrickson Papers
Trial puts niacin—and cholesterol dogma—in the line of fire
The Cholesterol Wars: The Skeptics vs the Preponderance of Evidence
Etymology:
“cholesterol” is derived from two Greek words ”Chole” means “bile” and Stereos” word means “solid”. It is soft waxy fats.
The name cholesterol comes from bile, which shows that it is in the digestive fluid and that it plays a role in fat metabolism.PMID: 19636418
It is the precursor of bile acid.
NOTE:Not all fats (Omega-3,6) are cholesterol, but all cholesterol is fat.
80% of total daily cholesterol production occurs in the liver and the intestines, normally about 2g depending on dietary intake. It is stored in the liver and the adrenal glands in high concentration and found only in animals and not plants.
The brain and the reproductive organs also produce at higher rates.
Plants have phytosterol and β-sitosterol, and yeast (fungus) have Ergosterol, which plays a similar role like cholesterol.
When a child is young, most of the cholesterol in their body comes from food. This is because the body organs doesn’t make enough cholesterol by itself (endogenous). Hence, breast milk does not only contain cholesterol, but it is also having higher content compared to kid formula.PMID: 27195698 PMID: 32876475 PMID: 24510467
In fact, It is higher in the post feeding samples compared to the samples obtained before feeding.
Older people may have a lower rate of cholesterol synthesis because of a reduced organ function or diseases. PMID: 31930729
Butter is not predictive of coronary heart disease.PMID: 9229205
Physico-chemical characterizations:Build and maintain the integrity of the cell membrane. It acts as a protective barrier by maintaining the fluidity, stability and regulating the passage (permeability) of molecules in and out of cells.PMID: 29874108 PMID: 28417231 PMID: 27150091
Communication:Plays a role in various cellular signaling pathways.
Acting as a specific ligand for proteins such as Smoothened (SMO) in the Hedgehog signaling pathway.PMID: 28700381 PMID: 30906624 PMID: 23847008
It is the precursor for the production of sex hormones like Testosterone, Estrogen, Progesterone and (corticosteroids) adrenal glands, including cortisol and aldosterone
It acts in Insulation of nerve fibers (myelin sheath) and helps transmit nerve signals efficiently.
Precursor of vitamin D and plays an important role in metabolism of vitamin A, D, E & K.
It is a precursor for bile acids, which help fat digestion and absorption.
Bile acids also act as signaling molecules (messenger/Communicator) that regulate blood glucose, fats, and energy metabolism. They change how gastrointestinal hormones, such as glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) and peptide YY (PYY), are made and how they work in the liver. The dysregulation (deficiency/imbalance of metabolism) of bile acid metabolism can lead to metabolic disorders.PMID: 33800566
Helps protect cells from oxidative stress by acting as an antioxidant. Hence, it is essential.
Cholesterol is not soluble in blood because blood contains a good amount of water and fats are hydrophobic. Hence, they need a special protein carrier called lipoprotein that is Low Density Lipoprotein (LDL) and High Density Lipoprotein (HDL) to transport from one place to other within the body; hence, they play an important role.
- Chylomicrons are very large particles type of lipoprotein that mainly carry dietary fats, including cholesterol (fatty acids from your food). They are made in the digestive system by intestinal cells and so are influenced by what you eat.
Chylomicron particles are the primary carrier of dietary (exogenous) cholesterol, while LDL particles are the primary carrier of endogenous cholesterol.PMID: 31846520 PMID: 29763186. The production and metabolism of chylomicron and LDL particles are different.PMID: 25974693 PMID: 29603652 - Very-low-density lipoprotein (VLDL) particles also carry triglycerides to tissues. But the liver makes them. As the body’s cells extract fatty acids from VLDLs, the particles turn into intermediate density lipoproteins, and, with further extraction, into LDL particles.PMID: 32646941
- Intermediate-density lipoprotein (IDL) particles form as VLDLs give up their fatty acids. Some are removed rapidly by the liver, and some are changed into low-density lipoproteins.
- Low-density lipoprotein (LDL) particles are smaller and even richer in pure cholesterol, since most of the triglycerides they carried are gone. LDL transports cholesterol from the liver to various tissues. PMID: 29603652 LDL is known as “bad” cholesterol because it delivers cholesterol to tissues and is strongly associated with the buildup of artery-clogging plaque.
- High-density lipoprotein (HDL) particles are called “good” cholesterol because some of them remove cholesterol from circulation and from artery walls and return it to the liver for excretion.
Low levels of LDL cholesterol may increase the risk for abnormalities such as cancer, premature birth, psychiatric disorders such as anxiety, depression, and suicide attempts. However, there is no evidence to suggest a direct link.PMID: 31097159
Their size also plays a crucial role, pattern “B” lipoprotein has small dense LDL particles while in pattern “A” the size of LDL particles are large.PMID: 22650003
Small, dense LDL particles are more likely to be oxidized, have a higher permeability in the endothelium of arterial walls, and are usually high in specific lysophospholipids, which suggests that they are more likely to be inflammatory. Therefore, small, dense LDL particles are more atherogenic (heart problems), dyslipidemia (high cholesterol), insulin resistance, type 2 diabetes, and metabolic syndrome than large LDL particles. PMID: 33586462 PMID: 32295829 PMID: 32276631 PMID: 34340681
Increased dietary cholesterol intakes may increase the size of LDL particles, and reduce the numbers of small, dense LDL particles.
A RCT, double-blind, placebo study & meta-analysis of RCT studies showed plant sterols at a dose of approximately 2–3 grams per day, consumed as part of healthy diets, may decrease LDL cholesterol levels by approximately 12-13%.PMID: 29795368 PMID: 24780090
Increased numbers of large HDL particles have been reported after dietary cholesterol intake.PMID: 29699812
Reduction of excess dietary carbohydrates and body weight also improved large HDL levels.PMID: 27847194
What is Apolipoprotein?
Apo-: the Greek word “apo,” which means “away from” or “separate.” The term “apolipoprotein” suggests that these proteins are involved in the separation and movement of fats.
Lipoproteins: The term “lipoproteins” is a combination of “fats” and “protein.”
Types and Functions:
ApoA: Associated with high-density lipoproteins (HDL). These lipoproteins are often referred to as “good cholesterol” because they help transport cholesterol away from tissues to the liver for elimination.
ApoB: Associated with low-density lipoproteins (LDL) and very low-density lipoproteins (VLDL). LDL is typically referred to as “bad cholesterol” because high levels can contribute to the buildup of cholesterol in arteries.
ApoC: Found in various lipoproteins and plays a role in regulating lipoprotein metabolism.
ApoE: Found in several lipoproteins, including VLDL, LDL, and HDL. It’s important for the metabolism of these lipoproteins and is associated with the clearance of cholesterol from the bloodstream.
ApoD, ApoF, ApoH, etc.: Some Other apolipoprotein with varying functions.
Phospholipids are associated with the brain (nerve tissue).
Part of the myelin sheath sphingomyyelin.
Palmitic and Stearic acids may stimulate cholesterol synthesis more than other dietary fatty acids.
Fatty acid-stimulated cholesterol production (biosynthesis) can contribute to increased serum cholesterol concentrations.
Plant sterols (adequate amounts) are well-known to inhibit intestinal cholesterol absorption significantly. Plant sterols have been found to change the expression of genes that control cholesterol transport and metabolism in the liver and small intestine PMID: 34787152 PMID: 30717222 PMID: 28158760. Dietary supplementation with plant sterols has been shown to reduce cholesterol absorption in the small intestine, PMID: 31413246. They are not absorbed from healthy intestinal cells in animals or humans.PMID: 30279620
MECHANISM:
One hypothesis is that plant sterols interact with cholesterol at the level of micelle formation (a small gathering of molecules with tails that stick together in the middle and heads that interact with the surrounding liquid. This phenomenon is actually really important in our bodies and when cooking, as it helps things like fats and oils mix with water-based substances, which allows us to digest and absorb nutrients and make delicious dishes!PMID: 34787152.
They interact with enzymes or transfer proteins at the level of intestinal cells.
Dietary fiber-rich foods such as whole oats, whole barley, legumes, peas, beans, flax seeds, apples, and citrus foods are another dietary agent with established cholesterol-lowering activities.PMID: 27807734
Three major biological mechanisms have been proposed to explain the cholesterol-reducing effects of soluble dietary fibres such as β-glucan from oats, pectin from Fruits and vegetables, guar gum and psyllium.
- Prevention of bile salt re-absorption from the small intestine, leading to an excess fecal bile salt excretion.
- Reduced glycemic response, leading to lower insulin stimulation of hepatic cholesterol synthesis.
- Physiological effects of fermentation products of SDF, mainly propionate.
- In vitro, bile salt micelles “bind” to SDF, preventing their re-absorption.PMID: 21776465.
Approximately 3 grams of β-glucan from oats, that is, 84 grams of oats/day (dosage depends on individuals), may lower LDL-cholesterol and total cholesterol levels by 7%, and 6%, respectively PMCID: PMC7258283 PMID: 31638148.
The consumption of 1 gram per day of pectin may reduce cholesterol levels by approximately 5 mg/dl.PMID: 22190137
Epidemiological and meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies have consistently reported an inverse association (eating more whole grains and its lowering heart health problems) between consumption of whole grain products and cardiovascular disease PMID: 32782386 PMID: 34277690 PMID: 32224906 PMID: 31146435 PMID: 31361320
Soy:Meta-analysis, Meta-Analysis of RCT studies have suggested a reduction of up to 3-4% to 7% in LDL cholesterol concentrations after consumption of adequate amounts of soy protein.PMID: 31006811
The approximate intake of 25 grams of soy protein may be sufficient to produce significant cholesterol-lowering effects, but there is no defined dose-response study. Further studies are needed to determine the optimal dosage.PMID: 33894258
RCT PMID: 28661316
Garlic:600 mg garlic allicor (Allium sativum) was associated with significant reductions in both total and LDL cholesterol levels by 7-8% and 12-14%, respectively.PMID: 25525386
The clinical trial showed no significant difference for raw or powdered garlic or garlic extract via injection, but not ingestion at a dose of approximately 4 grams per day for up to 6 months.PMID: 30479841
A meta-analysis of RCT, double-blind, placebo-controlled trials has revealed that different garlic preparations may exhibit varying effects. For instance, garlic powder and aged garlic extract have been found to be more effective in reducing serum Total Cholesterol levels, whereas garlic oil has been found to be more effective in lowering serum Total triglyceride levels.PMID: 22234974
Almond:
Systematic review and meta-analysis of RCT showed, consumption of 25–168 grams per day almonds may reduce in both total and LDL cholesterol levels or increase HDL cholesterol levels.PMID: 27752301 PMID: 28615375 PMID: 23251793
walnuts:
Meta-analysis and other studies have shown that consuming walnuts significantly lowers both total and approximately 9-16% LDL cholesterol levels.PMID: 24500935 PMID: 31030167 PMID: 15562184
Flaxseed:
Flaxseed contains several beneficial phytochemicals, including ALA and lignin, which reduces both total and LDL cholesterol, but currently, it is not well-established.PMID: 29779483
Saponins and flavonoids:
Saponins and flavonoids are natural compounds found in plants have been reported to have cholesterol-lowering activities.PMID: 33084093 PMID: 25479247
The Portfolio diet such as nuts, plant sterols, viscous fibers, and soy protein has been associated with significant reductions in LDL cholesterol levels and certain anti-inflammatory markers.PMID: 32615714
From a mechanistic standpoint, this makes sense. In the body, HDL acts to remove cholesterol from specialized cells called macrophages.
In some contexts, HDL can become damaged, transforming into something that actually promotes damage to our blood vessels.
The idea that raising HDL might be beneficial came from clinical studies, including the coronary Drug Trial (1965-1974), where the effects of niacin were examined.
Pharmaceutical labs are working on targeting a molecule in our body called cholesteryl ester transfer protein, more easily referred to as CETP. Studies have shown that blocking the action of CETP leads to an increase in HDL levels in the blood, and, based on the notion that increased HDL is beneficial, it is thought that these drugs would be a great option.
A CETP inhibitor drug produced by Pfizer was shown to increase HDL levels without significantly affecting LDL levels.
However, a clinical trial showed that when provided in combination with another cholesterol-lowering medication called a statin (we will get to these later), torcetrapib treatment was associated with a 50% increase in deaths from cardiovascular disease compared to the placebo. These results occurred because torcetrapib was reported to increase blood pressure.
Some criticisms regarding torcetrapib surrounded the idea that this was not a “pure” medication, especially considering that the blood pressure effect does not seem to be associated with the mechanism of torcetrapib action.Hence CETP inhibition has not been totally abandoned.
However, do HDL levels really matter if LDL levels are in check? In other words, is there any benefit to raising HDL levels if LDL levels are adequately treated? Conclusions from the AIM-HIGH study suggest that the answer is no. Statins are drugs that inhibit the natural ability of our body to generate cholesterol and result in the reduction of LDL cholesterol in the blood.
All statins have been reported to be associated with adverse side effects, especially when administered at high doses2. These side effects include memory problems, sleeping issues, and, most commonly, that which is associated with muscle. For some, these muscle issues might just be minor. For others, however, statin use may come with more serious muscle problems, and this is catching some attention (see this post by Laura Newman). Based on this, as well as results published in November of 2010 in the Lancet, which reported a significant increase in the number of patients experiencing a muscle condition called myopathy as a result of high-dose statins (80mg per day), the FDA has issued the following safety announcement.
The reported frequency of adverse side effects relating to statin usage is 5% in randomized clinical trials, but can reach up to 20% in the clinic3,4. It is thought that this discrepancy arises because of patient selection in these randomized clinical trials, which generally tend to exclude groups (such as women or the elderly) who have a higher rate of statin intolerance. Furthermore, patients who are heavy drinkers, those who have a pre-existing condition (such as diabetes), or those taking a cocktail of medications are typically excluded. Yet, these people are prescribed statins in real life.
Statin drugs break down muscle tissue excessively when you work, statin drugs interfere with mevalonate pathway in the liver which produces co enzymes q10 from precursors L-Tyrosine.
Framingham Heart Study:The Framingham Heart Study began the concept of studying multiple generations to understand heart diseases in 1948 with 5,209 adult men and women, aged between 30 and 62 years, with no history of heart attack or stroke. The primary goal of the study was to identify common factors that contribute to cardiovascular disease. The study originated in the town of Framingham, USA, is a long-term, ongoing cardiovascular cohort study.PMID: 5858592 It is a long-term, ongoing cardiovascular cohort study, publishing over 3,000 peer-reviewed scientific papers.
PMID: 24084292
1960:
- Cigarette smoking, obesity, Increased cholesterol and elevated blood pressure are associated with an increased risk of heart disease.
- Exercise is associated with a decreased risk of heart disease.
1970:
- In postmenopausal women, the risk of heart disease is increased, compared with premenopausal women.
- The interrelation of stress, social isolation and behavior (Psychosocial) factors affect the risk of heart disease.
1980:
- High levels of HDL cholesterol are associated with a lower risk of heart disease.
- There is no evidence to show that filtered cigarettes are less likely to get heart disease than cigarettes that don’t filter.
1990:
- Having an enlarged (hypertrophy) left ventricle of the heart is associated with an increased risk of stroke.
- Elevated blood pressure can progress to heart failure.
2000:
- “High normal blood pressure” called prehypertension in medicine; it is defined as a systolic pressure of 120–139 mm Hg and a diastolic pressure of 80–89 mm Hg) is associated with increased risk of cardiovascular disease. The lifetime risk of developing elevated blood pressure is 90%.
- Obesity is a risk factor for heart failure.
- Serum aldosterone levels predict risk of elevated blood pressure.
- Some genes increase the risk of atrial fibrillation.
Tazloc:
Tazloc (telmisartan) is an angiotensin (hormone) receptor blocker PMID: 34419631 PMID: 31330445
PMID: 32763272 PMID: 32356926.
Angiotensin is a peptide hormone that causes blood vessels to tighten (vasoconstriction) and an increase in blood pressure. It is part of the renin–angiotensin system, PMID: 31602467.
Angiotensin also causes (stimulate) the release of aldosterone (Hormone) to promote sodium retention by the kidneys PMID: 24206658 PMID: 34714114 PMID: 20720527.
It has a direct effect on the kidneys to increase sodium reabsorption, PMID: 25858030 PMID: 24694992.
In the brain increases the desire for salt, thirst sensation PMID: 28833692 PMID: 27991901 PMID: 21896148 and vasopressin (antidiuretic hormone) secretion PMID: 21123762 PMID: 11166690 PMID: 8876246 PMID: 8638700 PMID: 8876246.
Angiotensin increases fat mass by up regulating adipose tissue Lipogenesis (increases activities of lipogenic enzymes) and down regulating lipolysis.PMID: 16703000 PMID: 15181043 PMID 20944545 Means it helps in gaining fat and making it difficult to lose fat.
Tazloc works by blocking the action of an angiotensin II by relaxing blood vessels and lowers blood pressure to treat high blood pressure (hypertension) PMID: 10878697 PMID: 14513945 PMID: 4127309.
Tazloc can cause weight gain in some people through increased appetite, decreased metabolism and Fluid retention PMID: 12563538 PMID: 18382675 PMID: 32528286 PMID: 32587520 PMID: 31075789.
The exact mechanism of how it causes weight gain is not fully understood, PMID: 11603882 PMID: 31952459 PMID: 34575210
Cholesterol is an alcohol compound which cannot burn or oxidized like fat, it can only get rid of by the reverse transport of HDL system.
The body tightly controls cholesterol adsorption from food, most cholesterol is excreted, without any genetic problems average person absorbs less than 10% of cholesterol from food.
Cholesterol heated at high temperature gets oxysterols (which may be harmful:Theory)
Animal Studies
A 1970 study found mature rabbits have produced atherosclerosis of the main coronary arteries, apparently similar to those found in man.PMID: 5476254
A 1960 study found egg Yolk or Butter on the Development of Atherosclerosis in Swine.PMID: 13744173
In response to Seven Countries Study criticism, the true Health Initiative released a white paper, correcting what they felt were historical inaccuracies and errors that low-carb advocates had perpetuated.
A 1960 study found egg Yolk or Butter on the Development of Atherosclerosis in Pig. PMID: 13744173
The pig’s cardiovascular system and metabolism (body converts food into energy) are similar to humans. This makes them good models for studying diseases like atherosclerosis, but Pigs take a long time to develop these heart problems, and by the time they get big, sometimes up to 300 kg. Even smaller pig breeds for experiments can still grow to around 100 kg or more when fully grown. Taking care of and conducting experiments on them a bit tricky due to their size.PMID: 22444262
1909 first animal Study showed developing atherosclerosis in the aortic wall of herbivorous rabbits through feeding of a meat, milk, and eggs diet normally consumed by humans.
A 1970 study found mature rabbits have produced atherosclerosis of the main coronary arteries, apparently similar to those found in man.PMID: 5476254
In 1983 Further, this first animal Study got refined and became the first to report that cholesterol causes atheromatous changes in the vascular wall of fat-fed rabbits.PMID: 6340651
Anichkov describes macrophages, lymphocytes, foam cells found in atherosclerotic.
In 1950, two scientists (John W. Gofman and Frank Lindgren) established a connection between dietary cholesterol and atherosclerosis through LDL in the blood.PMID: 15403115
Using technology, they found out where cholesterol from food goes in the body, isolated different lipoproteins (LDL and HDL), found that LDL is the main carrier of cholesterol in the blood, and found that cholesterol is in plaques (atherosclerosis).
All this research laid the foundational groundwork for the establishment of LDL as “bad” cholesterol and a risk factor for atherosclerosis and cardiovascular disease in humans.
Even though their research was founded on human observations and epidemiological studies, subsequent research conducted in both human and animal models has consistently supported the correlation between elevated LDL cholesterol levels and the onset of atherosclerosis.
Birds have provided unique information about advanced stages of atherosclerosis, like initial thickness, necrosis, and infarction. Including the role of genetic factors, viruses, hypertension, and estrogens in susceptibility to atherosclerosis.PMID: 10090077
2010 Review Study Further understanding of fat biology: lessons from a fat fly. PMID: 19887892
In 2014, a review study which reviewed studies on fruit flies when are fed with high fat to study human obesity due to certain factors, PMID: 24508822
For studying nutrient sensing pathways and metabolic homeostasis, using fruit flies as a genetic model is an excellent way to provide insights into how obesity works in humans in a cost-effective, fast and efficient way.PMID: 18978647
In flies, the insulin/IGF functions play similar roles to what they do in humans.
Drug Approach: A drug used to treat diabetes in humans also affects sugar levels in flies, showing the same mechanism for controlling blood sugar.
Genetic Approach: Increasing or decreasing the activity of genes that promote energy storage or regulate energy balance leads to increased weight gain in flies, similar to how humans gain weight in obesity.PMID: 22828940
Dietary Approach:Feeding the flies a diet high in fats, sugars, and proteins leads to the flies developing features similar to obesity and related health issues in humans.PMID: 21035763
Rats are naturally well protected against atherosclerosis due to the high levels of HDL and simultaneously low levels of LDL and VLDL in the plasma.PMID: 21468891
Cats and dogs, like many carnivorous animals, have evolved with unique adaptations. One of these adaptations is a special network of blood vessels around their hearts, known as a coronary collateral network. This network of blood vessels acts as a natural safeguard for their hearts.
This network provides alternative routes for blood to flow around the heart. It serves as a backup system to maintain adequate blood flow and oxygen supply to the heart muscle, even when there’s a partial blockage, and hence it reduces the risk of myocardial infarction. In humans, these collateral vessels are often not as well-developed.
Hence, these animal are not suitable for atherosclerosis research.PMID: 19167915
Animal models have been an important tool for understanding the molecular mechanisms behind atherosclerotic how atherosclerotic plaque forms, progresses, and causes cardiovascular events. They are biologically very similar to humans. Mice share more than 98% DNA with humans.PMID: 28031915
Researchers uses small to large animals models depending on the specific questions they want to answer. In studying chronic vascular diseases like arteriosclerosis (hardening of the arteries), animal models are essential. This is because by the time people become patients with advanced arteriosclerosis, it’s often too late for effective intervention. So, researchers also need to study the early stages of these diseases and prevention strategies.
For practical research, it’s essential that these animal models are easy to find, handle, and don’t cost too much to maintain. They should have well-defined genetics, reproduce quickly, and be able to develop atherosclerosis without getting other diseases.
Animal testing is required by law before any new medicine or treatment can be tested on humans. This is to ensure the safety and effectiveness and to identify any possible side effects, such as toxicity, infertility, birth defects, or cancer-causing potential.PMID: 32328228
Animal research also benefits animals themselves, as many of the drugs and treatments developed for human use are now used to help animals live.PMID: 14988196
Pigs may not be a realistic model to study atherosclerosis due to many factors. PMID: 13744173
1) Differences in Lipid Metabolism: Pigs have high levels of HDL cholesterol, which is considered protective against atherosclerosis in humans.
- Limited Immune System Comparison: The immune response in pigs differs, particularly immune cells like macrophages and T-cells.
- Species-Specific Differences: Pigs and humans have differences in terms of vascular anatomy, hemodynamics, and plaque composition.
This difference makes it difficult to accurately replicate the human lipid profile and the development of atherosclerotic plaques.
Why did scientists carry out studies on vegetarian (rabbit) animals to eat something that is entirely different from their usual vegetarian food? PMID: 5476254
Vegetarian food, which is mostly Plant-based and Plant, doesn’t have Cholesterol, so feeding Cholesterol to a vegetarian animal wasn’t a wise decision.
Differences in Lipid Metabolism: Rabbits lack hepatic lipase activity, which means that the triglycerides carried by HDL in rabbits are not efficiently removed. This leads to the formation of triglyceride-rich HDL particles.PMID: 2930766
Long-term high cholesterol diets, commonly used in studies, can be harmful to rabbits’ livers, leading to mortality before the study concludes.PMID: 9467863
Rabbit cholesterol is mainly transported in HDL, while in humans, it’s primarily in LDL.PMID: 1078396
Differences in atherosclerosis formation: Rabbits rarely develop advanced atherosclerosis lesions like those in humans. While early fatty streaks are similar, rabbits don’t form the characteristic (typical) plaques seen in humans.
Differences in Inflammation: Inflammation Differences:Rabbits experience massive inflammation not reflective of human atherosclerosis.
In essence, using rabbits for atherosclerosis studies has significant differences from human conditions, making it less ideal for understanding the mechanisms of this disease in humans. Rabbits are highly sensitive to dietary cholesterol, possibly because their diet is rich in fiber, herbivore by nature and there is a fight between fat and fiber digestion. Their metabolism might be different.
In 1948, the first experiment was conducted to study the procedure of arteriosclerosis in the bird by giving diethylstilbestrol subcutaneously to maintain a sustained increase in the concentration of cholesterol, phospholipid, and neutral fat. This has shown to produce atherosclerosis of the aorta.PMID: 18881496
Atherosclerosis is seen occasionally, most frequently in birds, which is not due to their food (seed and grain). It probably because of their blood pressure is higher than in land animals. Fish-eating penguins are just as atherosclerotic as the birds.
Birds may not be a realistic model to study atherosclerosis due to many factors.
1) Physiological Differences: Birds have had a faster heart rate, different lipid metabolism, and unique circulatory systems.
2) Lack of LDL Cholesterol:Birds, particularly small birds, do not produce LDL cholesterol in the same way humans do.
3) Differences in Lipid Transport: Birds primarily transport lipids in the form of high-density lipoprotein (HDL) particles, while humans primarily use LDL.
Birds lack certain proteins (apoE and apoB48) and don’t form chylomicron when absorbing fat.PMID: 10090077
Additionally, birds carry various viruses that have been linked to the development of atherosclerosis.
1) Anatomy and Physiology Differences: Fruit flies have 9 hearts. The principal heart beats at about 370 times per minute. They have an open circulatory system, whereas humans have a closed circulatory system. The fly’s blood carries no oxygen because when they fly hard, the heart must pump faster to supply more oxygen to muscles. Therefore, flies get their oxygen through a system of tubes (22 small holes) connected directly to the atmosphere through the sides of the fly’s body.
2) Short Lifespan:The average life span of a fruit fly is only 30 days.
3) Differences in Lipid Transport: The way PPARγ functions in flies is not similar to its role in human biology because flies lack adipose tissue.PMID: 19887892
Do carnivore animals become atherosclerotic?
No, based on limited research, there is no consensus regarding whether carnivore animals specifically exhibit atherosclerotic changes.
They develop a milder form of atherosclerosis than seen in humans, even though they live entirely on animal food.
Why is it that vascular changes, similar to human atherosclerosis, occur in vegetarians, but not in meat-eating animals?
Is it the food that’s causing it?
If that is the case, how can atherosclerosis and coronary heart disease be seen in zoo animals fed with their natural food?
To study that, scientists need to make two groups of animals in a lab. One group gets fat food and the other group gets its natural food.
Why don’t animals get a heart attack even though they get atherosclerosis?
Does atherosclerosis cause heart disease, or something else?
It’s important to clarify that In 1950 (John W. Gofman and Frank Lindgren) research primarily focused on human observations and epidemiological studies, it was not based on controlled animal experiments.
Animal testing is required by law before any new medicine or treatment can be tested on humans2. This is to ensure the safety and effectiveness of the potential therapy, and to identify any possible side effects, such as toxicity, infertility, birth defects, or cancer-causing potential1.
Observational Studies
In response to Seven Countries Study criticism, the true Health Initiative released a white paper, correcting what they felt were historical inaccuracies and errors that low-carb advocates had perpetuated.
Populations with higher intakes of dietary cholesterol had higher rates of heart disease.
In 1910, Windaus reported that atherosclerotic plaques from aortas of human subjects contained over 20-fold higher concentrations of cholesterol than did normal aortas. PMID: 21516151
In 2016, Meta-analysis and Population Studies, showed that Dietary Cholesterol Matter.PMID: 27739004
In 2018,A review study showed higher dietary cholesterol intake is associated with increased levels of blood total cholesterol and LDL -C which are risk factors for cardiovascular disease.
In 2019, a study followed 6 prospective US cohorts for 17.5 years between 1985 and 2016. Studies have shown that a higher intake of cholesterol or eggs is linked to an increased risk of cardiovascular disease and death.PMID: 30877091
Studies and projects involving Dr. Ancel Keys that were supposed to be published were purposefully hidden in dusty basements for decades.PMID: 27617709
Ancel Keys’ Seven Countries Study involved Greece, Italy, South Africa, Spain, Finland, and Japan, but originally, it also included more nations, prompting accusations of cherry-picking data. Did he purposely choose the countries that he knew would better represent his hypothesis? PMID: 9131696
Keys has received criticism from the low-carbohydrate diet community, the Study excluded countries that did not fit his hypothesis.PMID: 29121230
1) Countries were selected and excluded based on a desired outcome.
2) France, a high-fat, low-heart disease country, was purposefully excluded from the survey.
3) A distortion was introduced by dietary data taken during Lent in Greece.
4) Sugar was not considered as a possible contributor to coronary heart disease.
5) The study focused on correlations rather than causation.
Mid-20th Century epidemiological studies showed a correlation between dietary fat and cholesterol intake and heart disease rates in seven different countries, as well as evidence from autopsy studies, observations of arterial plaques, and experimental studies, which led to the “Lipid Hypothesis.”
In the latter half of the 20th century, dietary guidelines were established by Public Health campaigns to reduce dietary saturated fat and restrict the consumption of cholesterol-rich foods, such as eggs and certain animal products, based on the Lipid Hypothesis. This changed the market. Food manufacturers started replacing ingredients that were high in saturated fat were with alternative unsaturated fats, vegetable oils, and synthetic fats. Food labels began to display “cholesterol-free” on packaging. On the other hand, due to growing awareness of the relationship between dietary fat and heart health, consumer demand for low-fat foods as a result, food manufacturers saw a market opportunity.“Low-fat” and “fat-free” categories of foods were introduced.
In the late 20th Century and Beyond, Some studies showed that dietary cholesterol had a relatively modest impact on blood cholesterol levels; hence, researchers began to question the simplistic, direct and linear relationship between dietary cholesterol intake and blood cholesterol levels. In the past, it was commonly believed that the more dietary cholesterol intake, the higher blood cholesterol levels were expected. This contributed to the perception that reducing dietary cholesterol intake would lead to lower blood cholesterol levels. But after studying the Cholesterol Homeostasis, it becomes more clear that the body tightly regulates cholesterol levels through a complex feedback system.
Understanding of the process of atherosclerosis pathologies remains incomplete.
Oxidative stress PMID: 1752940 (Witztum and Steinberg, 1991), inflammation PMID: 9887164 (Ross, 1999), hyperhomocyst(e)inemia PMID: 9361570 (Moghadasian et al., 1997), infection PMID: 10920732 (Fong, 2000), and diabetic atherosclerosis PMID: 11994261(Grundy et al., 2002)
All the above factors are linked with atherosclerosis.
Studies and Mechanism
Cellular membranes are not exclusively made up of saturated fats.
The composition of fat in the diet can influence the fat composition of cell membranes.PMID: 1916101
It is recommended that patients with a defined cardiovascular risk limit their intake to no more than 200 mg of dietary cholesterol per day.
It is impossible to build cell walls and nerve fibers without cholesterol.PMID: 9388216 PMID: 11089578
The chemical processes necessary for the creation of nerve impulses are also dependent on cholesterol PMID: 29684511 PMID: 17111927
Cholesterol is so important that all cells can produce it by themselves, PMID: 25309573
STUDIES
2019 Study showed that egg intake increases in large HDL in all individuals. PMCID: PMC6818912
2022 study showed that there is not a direct correlation between cholesterol intake and blood cholesterol.PMID: 35631308
Cholesterol plays a role as a precursor for hormones like cortisol and aldosterone, and these hormones play roles in regulating inflammation and blood pressure. It was hypothesized that excess cholesterol might contribute to an overproduction of these hormones, and lead to heart disease. Again Correlation! Later studies showed that the connection between dietary cholesterol and the specific production of hormones related to heart disease is not direct or important as initially hypothesized. Other factors like inflammation, oxidative stress, insulin resistance in heart disease have become better understood.PMID: 29914176
PMID: 30170598
MECHANISM
Cholesterol production in the liver is influenced by multiple factors, including
Dietary intake: When dietary cholesterol intake increases, the body reduces self (endogenous) cholesterol production that is feedback inhibition by producing less HMG-CoA reductase, an enzyme that is essential for cholesterol synthesis.
When the body has too much LDL cholesterol, it produces more LDL receptors, helping the body to remove LDL cholesterol from the blood to maintain cholesterol levels.
When dietary cholesterol intake is low, the body can produce cholesterol from scratch, starting with acetyl-CoA through De novo cholesterol synthesis.
The body may increase its absorption thorough intestine (mechanism) to maintain a balance.
It depends on the body’s overall cholesterol needs.
The impact of dietary fiber, carbohydrates, and specific nutrients on cholesterol metabolism was recognized.
The body can excrete cholesterol in the bile.
If 200 to 300 mg (1 egg yolk has about 200 mg) of cholesterol a day is consumed, the liver will produce an additional 800 milligrams per day from raw materials such as fat, sugars, and proteins.
Conflicting evidences-The effect of dietary cholesterol on HDL composition is complex and may depend on the duration and amount of cholesterol intake. One study found that a short-term elevation in dietary cholesterol and fat intake increased HDL lipid hydroperoxide content and serum amyloid A-levels, indicating dysfunctional HDL. Another study showed that dietary cholesterol increased both LDL and HDL levels, but did not alter the LDL cholesterol/HDL cholesterol ratio. Another study shown to increase the size of both LDL and HDL particles, with implications for a less atherogenic LDL particle and more functional HDL in reverse cholesterol transport. PMID: 27103896 PMID: 23016129 PMID: 29203475
Genetic factors: Some individuals are hyper-responders, means their body increases blood cholesterol levels in response to dietary cholesterol, while others are less sensitive.PMID: 3328488
The “hyper-responders” absorb dietary cholesterol more easily than the “hypo-responders.” PMID: 22037012
The levels of both LDL and HDL cholesterol rise
in the “hyper-responder” subjects following consumption of dietary cholesterol.PMID: 23016129
PMID: 21385506
Dietary cholesterol may not increase cardiovascular risk much because the LDL/HDL ratio stays the same, no matter how much people respond to dietary cholesterol.PMID: 31838890
PMID: 31838890
Approximately 50% of the general population are“hypo-responders” PMID: 10773393 PMID: 3544818
STUDIES
2010 RCT study, 12 weeks of eating 550 mg/d (3 whole eggs) of additional dietary cholesterol did not increase LDL cholesterol levels but significantly increased
HDL cholesterol levels, reductions in plasma tumor necrosis factor-α, and serum amyloid A were seen in the EGG group only in subjects with confirmed metabolic syndrome. PMID: 24079288
The 2006 crossover study showed that both “hyper-responders” and “hypo-responders”,29 women (50–68 y) and 13 men (60–80 y) increased their cholesterol levels by the same amount after eating 3 eggs (640 mg cholesterol/d) for 3 weeks.PMID: 16398934
1990 double-blind, crossover 4 weeks study showed that hypercholesterolemic and normocholesterolemic with high BMI men and women eating 700 mg/day cholesterol (egg) increases in HDL particle size.PMID: 2344298
MECHANISM
Increased size and cholesterol concentrations of HDL particles may indicate changes in cholesterol-reverse transport (CRT) mechanisms. The concept of CRT may be regarded as an anti-atherogenic pathway through which peripheral cholesterol is transferred to the liver for further metabolism. Other regulatory proteins, including Lecithin cholesterol acyltransferase (LCAT) and cholesteryl ester
transfer protein (CETP) may regulate the CRT pathway. Dietary cholesterol may have an impact on the activity of these proteins.PMID: 34746320 PMID: 34444804 PMID: 34637925 PMID: 31071007 PMID: 30610681 PMID: 35921880 PMID: 16319046
Hormonal signals:
The balance between body self production (endogenous) and (exogenous) dietary cholesterol intake is a complex, depends on many factors and is still not fully understood.
Current understanding:Our understanding of cholesterol metabolism is still evolving, right now in the 21st Century, current understanding of studies has shifted focus from simply restricting or reducing dietary cholesterol to emphasizing a balanced diet which includes fat foods like eggs and ghee. Cholesterol is not the sole determinant of heart disease risk. Dietary recommendations have shifted from reducing dietary cholesterol to promoting cholesterol intake that considers overall nutrient density.
Countries eating high amounts of fat were also eating more sugar. Experts like Professor John Yudkin maintained that sugar was to blame.
CONTROVERSY
The Heart attack or cardiac (heart) arrest idea is greatly simplified, this idea proposes that dietary fats rich in saturated fatty acids raise the concentration of cholesterol in the blood. This in turn is involved in the formation of arteriosclerosis (blockage), which restricts the blood flow to the heart muscle (myocardium), and its tendency to form thrombi (clots in blood vessel), leading to myocardial infarction.
Is lowering blood cholesterol actually doing harm?
Even when cardiovascular deaths have been reduced in some clinical trials, subjects have died from other causes, sometimes cancer, sometimes suicide, or other forms of violence, resulting in no overall change in death rate.